Presidents of Evergreen Cemetery Association
- Jesse Dodge 1863-1864
- Rufus O. Dodge 1864-1868
- Albert Winslow 1868-1877
- George W. Webb 1877-1878
- David W. Curtis 1878-1892, 1896-1897
- H.A. Porter 1892-1896
- D.S. Damuth 1897-1914
- W. O. Hoffman 1914-1929
- William Spaeth 1929-1933
- George Kiesling 1933-1940
- Frederick W. Bienfang 1940-1954
- Lucius L. Klement 1954-1972
- Wesley Jung 1972-1973
- Harold Gruetzman 1973-1985
- Harlow Kutz 1985-1987
- Elmore Klement 1987-1988
- Edward Sexton 1988-1990
- Harvey Welcher 1990-1997
- Gordon Day 1997-1999
- Donald Wahl 1999-2000
- Bradford W. Wilcox 2000-present
Sextons of Evergreen Cemetery
- F. J. Roberts 1863-1864
- Daniel W. Gilman 1864-1867
- Franklin Roberts 1867-1877
- N. D. Hardin 1877-1887
- Liberty Lowell 1887-1889
- John W. Frohmader 1889-1894 (first sexton to reside in sexton’s house)
- DeWitt Wilcox 1894-1902
- Fred Smith 1902-1903
- August Hansen 1903-1904
- Herman Hausen 1904-1910
- Fred W. Bienfang 1910-1920
- Herman Siegle 1920-1934
- Helmuth Hebbe 1934-1942
- Irving Henze 1942
- Frederick W. Bienfang 1943-1954
- Albert Scidmore 1954-1965*
- Mike L. Boese 1965-1974*
- J. Linus Endl 1974 (5 months)*
- Owen Wilkenson 1974-1989*
- June Smith 1990-1997
- Neal Traeder 1998-present
* Title was Superintendent.